Is Google about to destroy the web?
Is Google About to Destroy the Web?
Introduction
For decades, Google has been the undisputed gatekeeper of the internet. Its search engine processes over 8.5 billion queries per day, dictating what content gets seen and what gets buried. But in recent years, critics have raised concerns that Google’s dominance—coupled with its aggressive push into AI, changes in search algorithms, and self-preferencing practices—might be harming the open web rather than helping it.
The question now is: Is Google on the verge of destroying the web as we know it?
To answer this, we must examine:
How Google’s search monopoly shapes the internet
The impact of AI (like Gemini) on content discovery
The decline of organic traffic for publishers
Google’s self-preferencing (promoting its own services over competitors)
The future of an independent web vs. a Google-controlled internet
Let’s dive in.
1. Google’s Search Monopoly and Its Grip on the Web
Google controls over 90% of the global search market. This dominance gives it unparalleled power to decide:
Which websites rank at the top
What content gets traffic (and revenue)
Which businesses succeed or fail
The Problem with Algorithm Updates
Google frequently updates its algorithms (Panda, Penguin, Hummingbird, BERT, etc.), often leaving publishers scrambling to adapt. Each change can wipe out entire sites from search results, destroying businesses overnight.
Example: The "Medic Update" (2018) devastated health and wellness sites, favoring big-name publishers like WebMD.
Example: The "Helpful Content Update" (2022) penalized sites deemed "unhelpful," but many high-quality independent creators were caught in the crossfire.
Zero-Click Searches: Starving Publishers of Traffic
A growing number of Google searches now end without users clicking through to external websites. Instead, Google provides answers directly in search results (via featured snippets, Knowledge Panels, and AI-generated summaries).
Stat: According to SparkToro, ~60% of Google searches end without a click to another site.
Impact: Publishers lose traffic, ad revenue, and the ability to sustain their businesses.
2. AI and the Death of Organic Search?
Google is aggressively integrating AI into search with Gemini (formerly Bard) and AI Overviews. The company now generates answers instead of just linking to external sources.
How AI Search Hurts the Web
Fewer clicks to websites: If Google’s AI provides full answers, why visit a publisher’s site?
Less revenue for creators: No clicks = no ad impressions, no affiliate sales, no subscriptions.
Centralization of knowledge: Instead of a diverse web, information becomes controlled by Google’s AI.
The "Enshittification" of Search
Tech writer Cory Doctorow coined the term "enshittification" to describe how platforms degrade over time—first serving users, then businesses, and finally extracting maximum value for themselves.
Phase 1 (Early Google): Great results, unbiased rankings.
Phase 2 (2010s): More ads, self-promotion (Flights, Hotels, Shopping).
Phase 3 (Now): AI answers keep users inside Google’s ecosystem, starving the open web.
3. The Decline of Publisher Traffic
Independent publishers, bloggers, and small businesses are seeing catastrophic drops in organic traffic.
Case Studies:
The Atlantic: Reported a 40% decline in Google traffic in 2023.
Gizmodo & Jezebel: Saw traffic collapses leading to layoffs and shutdowns.
Small businesses: Many report 80-90% traffic loss after algorithm updates.
Why This Matters
If publishers can’t make money from the web, they’ll:
Shut down
Resort to clickbait and sensationalism
Depend on platforms like Google and Facebook (further centralizing control)
4. Google’s Self-Preferencing Problem
Google doesn’t just organize the web—it competes with it.
Examples of Self-Preferencing:
Google Flights (outranks Expedia, Kayak)
Google Hotels (outranks Booking.com)
YouTube (dominates video search over Vimeo, Dailymotion)
Google Shopping (replaces Amazon/eCommerce listings)
EU Fines & Antitrust Cases
The EU fined Google €4.34 billion for favoring its own shopping service.
The U.S. DOJ lawsuit (2023) accuses Google of monopolistic practices.
Yet, despite legal battles, Google continues to prioritize its own services.
5. The Future: Will Google Kill the Web?
Possible Scenarios:
Google Becomes the Internet (AI answers replace websites entirely).
Publishers Revolt (sites block Google’s AI crawlers, demand payment for content).
Regulation Forces Change (governments break up Google’s monopoly).
Alternative Search Rises (DuckDuckGo, Brave Search, decentralized search gains traction).
What Can Be Done?
Support independent search engines (like Kagi, which pays publishers).
Push for antitrust enforcement (breaking up Google’s ad-tech monopoly).
Encourage direct traffic (newsletters, subscriptions, social media not controlled by algorithms).
0 Comments